第三季度,盡管面對惡性通脹和加息,美國人仍在報復性消費,這使美國經濟達到自2021年末以來的最快增長速度。
據勞工統計局(Bureau of Labor Statistics,BLS)上周四公布的所謂先行估計顯示,第三季度,實際國民生產總值(GDP)按年計算增長速度為4.9%。這遠高于第二季度的2.1%。勞工統計局解釋稱,最新數據得益于聯邦和州政府增加支出、出口增長和企業的庫存投資。
多年來,華爾街不斷發布有關經濟衰退的預測,因此拜登政府很快為美國經濟的大幅增長彈冠相慶。自2022年6月美國通脹率驟升至超過9%的四十年最高水平以來,有許多專家不斷警告,美聯儲若想恢復消費物價穩定,可能需要持續加息,直到經濟陷入衰退。但拜登總統駁斥了這種觀點。
他在一份聲明中說道:“我從不認為需要靠經濟衰退來降低通脹。今天,我們再次看到美國經濟在通脹下降的同時持續增長。這證明了在拜登經濟學,也就是我提出的通過壯大中產階級發展經濟這一計劃的支持下,美國消費者和美國工人所具有的韌性。”
華爾街大感意外
許多經濟學家和華爾街分析師依舊擔心加息和惡性通脹會引發經濟衰退,GDP創下最大增幅令他們感到意外。有人甚至表示,美國最近的GDP報告只是經濟增長放緩前最后的狂歡。
銀率網(Bankrate)高級經濟分析師馬克·哈姆里克表示:“仔細研究一下對第三季度GDP的估算,因為這可能是我們在最近一段時間能看到的最快增長速度。”
哈姆里克表示,美國經濟依舊面臨“巨大的阻力”,包括美聯儲“長期維持更高”利率的政策、大幅上漲的美國國債收益率,以及華盛頓因聯邦預算陷入僵局導致美國政府在11月部分停擺的可能性。除此之外,隨著俄烏沖突和以色列-哈馬斯沖突持續,地緣政治動蕩的威脅加劇。
哈姆里克評論美國經濟稱:“由于存在不確定性因素,中期的預期不容樂觀。無法保證最近的強勁增長勢頭能夠持續下去。”
惠譽評級(Fitch Ratings)美國經濟總監奧盧·索諾拉認為,GDP數據證明第三季度美國經濟增長“從韌性轉向了再加速”,沒有受到美聯儲激進加息的沖擊。但她警告,美國經濟目前的強勁勢頭并不會讓美聯儲應對通脹的努力變得更輕松,而且美聯儲主席杰羅姆·鮑威爾可能很快會加息并維持高利率,從而終止經濟持續增長的勢頭。
她警告稱:“美聯儲長期維持更高利率的態度,可能持續更長時間。歸根結底,此次經濟大幅增長的勢頭能否持續值得懷疑;高于趨勢的經濟增長基本上不可能與日益限制性的利率環境并存。”
經濟學家認為不要過于興奮
上周四的GDP報告發布后,盡管經濟表現強勢,但有許多經濟學家們很快發出警告。雖然上個季度消費支出年增長率達到4%,為2021年第四季度以來的最大漲幅,但LPL Financial的首席經濟學家杰弗里·羅奇認為,這是消費者“最后的喘息”。他說道:“真正的問題是,這種趨勢能否持續到未來幾個季度。我們的觀點是否定的。”
今年暑假,在強勁的勞動力市場和疫情期間積攢的過度儲蓄的支持下,美國人紛紛前往參加泰勒·斯威夫特的演唱會和觀看《芭比》(Barbie)、《奧本海默》(Oppenheimer)等電影。然而,在加息的影響下,隨著儲蓄耗盡和勞動力市場降溫,羅奇認為消費者會“逐漸結束消費狂歡,減少開支”。
他還指出,第三季度企業設備投資減少,這證明加息“給企業帶來了壓力”。他還解釋稱,第三季度的GDP數據有1.3個百分點來自企業重建庫存,而“考慮到庫存管理的性質”,這種趨勢不太可能持續。
摩根士丹利(Morgan Stanley)首席美國經濟學家艾倫·曾特納在一份報告中對這些觀點表達了支持。她表示,第三季度的數據受到了庫存重建趨勢的推動,而未來幾個季度,由于“庫存減少的拖累”,GDP增長將會放緩。她的團隊目前對第四季度GDP增速的預測只有0.7%。
曾特納寫道:“我們預計,在更緊縮的貨幣政策和日益緊張的財務環境的累加影響下,到年底經濟增速會大幅放緩。”
最悲觀的前景預測
安永(EY)首席經濟學家格雷戈里·達科也擔心,在第三季度強勁的GDP報告之后,可能好景不長。
他在周四表示:“雖然經濟強勁增長的跡象會讓更多人認為美國經濟正在重新加速,但我們并不認為這種強勁的勢頭能夠持續。消費者和企業將會更廣泛地感受到成本疲勞、償債成本增加和就業增長放緩的影響。”
但并非所有專家都持悲觀態度。哈里斯金融集團(Harris Financial Group)主理合伙人杰米·考克斯表示,第三季度的GDP報告表明,加息并不像人們之前預測的那樣對經濟或股市造成了嚴重沖擊。
他說道:“投資者認為,經濟增長的唯一條件是零利率政策[ZIRP],這種假設顯然是不正確的。在美國,迄今為止,利率已經實現了控制通脹的目標,但并沒有因此影響經濟增長或就業。”(財富中文網)
翻譯:劉進龍
審校:汪皓
第三季度,盡管面對惡性通脹和加息,美國人仍在報復性消費,這使美國經濟達到自2021年末以來的最快增長速度。
據勞工統計局(Bureau of Labor Statistics,BLS)上周四公布的所謂先行估計顯示,第三季度,實際國民生產總值(GDP)按年計算增長速度為4.9%。這遠高于第二季度的2.1%。勞工統計局解釋稱,最新數據得益于聯邦和州政府增加支出、出口增長和企業的庫存投資。
多年來,華爾街不斷發布有關經濟衰退的預測,因此拜登政府很快為美國經濟的大幅增長彈冠相慶。自2022年6月美國通脹率驟升至超過9%的四十年最高水平以來,有許多專家不斷警告,美聯儲若想恢復消費物價穩定,可能需要持續加息,直到經濟陷入衰退。但拜登總統駁斥了這種觀點。
他在一份聲明中說道:“我從不認為需要靠經濟衰退來降低通脹。今天,我們再次看到美國經濟在通脹下降的同時持續增長。這證明了在拜登經濟學,也就是我提出的通過壯大中產階級發展經濟這一計劃的支持下,美國消費者和美國工人所具有的韌性。”
華爾街大感意外
許多經濟學家和華爾街分析師依舊擔心加息和惡性通脹會引發經濟衰退,GDP創下最大增幅令他們感到意外。有人甚至表示,美國最近的GDP報告只是經濟增長放緩前最后的狂歡。
銀率網(Bankrate)高級經濟分析師馬克·哈姆里克表示:“仔細研究一下對第三季度GDP的估算,因為這可能是我們在最近一段時間能看到的最快增長速度。”
哈姆里克表示,美國經濟依舊面臨“巨大的阻力”,包括美聯儲“長期維持更高”利率的政策、大幅上漲的美國國債收益率,以及華盛頓因聯邦預算陷入僵局導致美國政府在11月部分停擺的可能性。除此之外,隨著俄烏沖突和以色列-哈馬斯沖突持續,地緣政治動蕩的威脅加劇。
哈姆里克評論美國經濟稱:“由于存在不確定性因素,中期的預期不容樂觀。無法保證最近的強勁增長勢頭能夠持續下去。”
惠譽評級(Fitch Ratings)美國經濟總監奧盧·索諾拉認為,GDP數據證明第三季度美國經濟增長“從韌性轉向了再加速”,沒有受到美聯儲激進加息的沖擊。但她警告,美國經濟目前的強勁勢頭并不會讓美聯儲應對通脹的努力變得更輕松,而且美聯儲主席杰羅姆·鮑威爾可能很快會加息并維持高利率,從而終止經濟持續增長的勢頭。
她警告稱:“美聯儲長期維持更高利率的態度,可能持續更長時間。歸根結底,此次經濟大幅增長的勢頭能否持續值得懷疑;高于趨勢的經濟增長基本上不可能與日益限制性的利率環境并存。”
經濟學家認為不要過于興奮
上周四的GDP報告發布后,盡管經濟表現強勢,但有許多經濟學家們很快發出警告。雖然上個季度消費支出年增長率達到4%,為2021年第四季度以來的最大漲幅,但LPL Financial的首席經濟學家杰弗里·羅奇認為,這是消費者“最后的喘息”。他說道:“真正的問題是,這種趨勢能否持續到未來幾個季度。我們的觀點是否定的。”
今年暑假,在強勁的勞動力市場和疫情期間積攢的過度儲蓄的支持下,美國人紛紛前往參加泰勒·斯威夫特的演唱會和觀看《芭比》(Barbie)、《奧本海默》(Oppenheimer)等電影。然而,在加息的影響下,隨著儲蓄耗盡和勞動力市場降溫,羅奇認為消費者會“逐漸結束消費狂歡,減少開支”。
他還指出,第三季度企業設備投資減少,這證明加息“給企業帶來了壓力”。他還解釋稱,第三季度的GDP數據有1.3個百分點來自企業重建庫存,而“考慮到庫存管理的性質”,這種趨勢不太可能持續。
摩根士丹利(Morgan Stanley)首席美國經濟學家艾倫·曾特納在一份報告中對這些觀點表達了支持。她表示,第三季度的數據受到了庫存重建趨勢的推動,而未來幾個季度,由于“庫存減少的拖累”,GDP增長將會放緩。她的團隊目前對第四季度GDP增速的預測只有0.7%。
曾特納寫道:“我們預計,在更緊縮的貨幣政策和日益緊張的財務環境的累加影響下,到年底經濟增速會大幅放緩。”
最悲觀的前景預測
安永(EY)首席經濟學家格雷戈里·達科也擔心,在第三季度強勁的GDP報告之后,可能好景不長。
他在周四表示:“雖然經濟強勁增長的跡象會讓更多人認為美國經濟正在重新加速,但我們并不認為這種強勁的勢頭能夠持續。消費者和企業將會更廣泛地感受到成本疲勞、償債成本增加和就業增長放緩的影響。”
但并非所有專家都持悲觀態度。哈里斯金融集團(Harris Financial Group)主理合伙人杰米·考克斯表示,第三季度的GDP報告表明,加息并不像人們之前預測的那樣對經濟或股市造成了嚴重沖擊。
他說道:“投資者認為,經濟增長的唯一條件是零利率政策[ZIRP],這種假設顯然是不正確的。在美國,迄今為止,利率已經實現了控制通脹的目標,但并沒有因此影響經濟增長或就業。”(財富中文網)
翻譯:劉進龍
審校:汪皓
Americans continued their revenge spending in the third quarter despite persistent inflation and rising interest rates, helping the U.S. economy grow at its fastest pace since late 2021.
Real gross domestic product (GDP) grew at a 4.9% annual rate last quarter, according to the so-called advance estimate that the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported Thursday. That’s up from just 2.1% in the second quarter. The latest figure was buoyed by rising federal and state government spending, increased exports, and inventory investments from businesses, the BLS explained.
The Biden administration was quick to celebrate the surge in U.S. economic growth after years of consistent recession predictions from Wall Street. Ever since inflation surged to a four-decade high of over 9% in June 2022, a chorus of experts has repeatedly warned that the Federal Reserve may need to hike interest rates until the economy slips into recession if it truly wants to restore price stability for consumers. But President Biden rebuked that thinking on Thursday.
“I never believed we would need a recession to bring inflation down—and today we saw again that the American economy continues to grow even as inflation has come down,” he said in a statement. “It is a testament to the resilience of American consumers and American workers, supported by Bidenomics—my plan to grow the economy by growing the middle class.”
A big surprise on Wall Street
The latest surge in GDP surprised many economists and Wall Street analysts who still fear rising interest rates and stubborn inflation could spark a recession. Some even argued Thursday the latest GDP report was merely the last hurrah of a slowing economy.
“Take a good look at the estimate for third-quarter GDP because it could be the highest that we see for a while,” Mark Hamrick, a senior economic analyst at Bankrate, said.
Hamrick noted the economy still faces “substantial headwinds,” including the Federal Reserve’s “higher for longer” interest rate policy, surging Treasury yields, and the potential for a partial federal government shutdown in November due to gridlock in Washington over the federal budget. On top of that, the threat of geopolitical instability is rising as the Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Hamas conflicts continue.
“Expectations are muted for the intermediate term amid no shortage of sources of uncertainty,” Hamrick said of the economy. “There’s no guarantee that recent substantial momentum can be sustained.”
Olu Sonola, head of U.S. economics at Fitch Ratings, argued the GDP numbers were evidence that economic growth “transitioned from resilience to reacceleration” in the third quarter, defying the Fed’s aggressive interest rate hikes. But she warned that the economy’s current strength won’t make the Fed’s inflation-fighting job any easier, and Chair Jerome Powell is likely to end the economic-growth winning streak soon by raising rates and keeping them elevated.
“The Fed’s higher for longer message may turn out to be much higher for much longer,” she warned. “The bottom line is that the staying power of this growth spurt is questionable going forward; above-trend economic growth cannot sustainably coexist alongside an increasingly restrictive interest rate environment.”
Don’t get too excited, economists say
A number of economists were quick to share words of warning after the GDP report on Thursday, despite its strength. Even though consumer spending rose at a 4% annual rate last quarter, marking the largest increase since the fourth quarter of 2021, Jeffrey Roach, chief economist at LPL Financial, argued that it’s a last gasp from consumers. “The real question is if the trend can continue in the coming quarters, and we think not,” he said.
Americans headed to Taylor Swift concerts and movies like Barbie and Oppenheimer in droves this summer, supported by the strong labor market and excess savings built up during the pandemic. But as those savings run dry and the labor market cools under the weight of rising interest rates, Roach believes that consumers will “wind down their spending splurge.”
He also noted that corporate investment for equipment shrank in the third quarter, evidence that rising rates have “put a strain on businesses.” And he explained that the third-quarter GDP numbers were boosted 1.3 percentage points by businesses rebuilding their inventories—a trend that is unlikely to continue “given the nature of inventory management.”
Morgan Stanley’s chief U.S. economist Ellen Zentner backed up those comments in a Thursday note, arguing that GDP growth will slow in the coming quarters owing to a “drag from inventory drawdown” after the third-quarter numbers were given a “boost” from inventory rebuilding. Her team is currently tracking fourth-quarter GDP at just 0.7%.
“We expect to see significant slowing into the end of the year, with the cumulative effect of tighter monetary policy and tightening financial conditions,” Zentner wrote.
A mostly bearish outlook
EY chief economist Gregory Daco also fears the good times won’t last after the strong third-quarter GDP report.
“While these signs of economic strength will fuel speculations that the economy is reaccelerating, we do not expect such strong momentum will be sustained,” he said Thursday. “Cost fatigue, rising debt servicing costs, and slowing job growth are about to be felt more widely by consumers and businesses.”
Still, not every expert was bearish. Jamie Cox, managing partner for Harris Financial Group, said the third-quarter GDP report shows that rising interest rates may not be as deadly for the economy, or stocks, as previously anticipated.
“Investors think ZIRP [zero interest rate policy] is the only condition which permits the economy to grow, and that is clearly an incorrect assumption,” he said. “In the U.S. so far, interest rates have accomplished the objective of stifling inflation, but not at the expense of economic growth or employment.”