對老板說“不”
????你去找老板,告訴他項目被延誤或者成本超支,得到的回應卻是“謝謝你”,你能想象這樣的情景嗎? ????實際上,門羅創新公司(Menlo Innovations)就是這樣規定的。這家位于美國密歇根州安阿伯市的軟件公司對所有項目經理進行了培訓,要求他們面帶微笑,即使從員工那里聽到的是壞消息,也要表示感謝。 ????26歲的麗莎?何便在門羅公司擔任項目經理,她表示:“我需要說的是:‘謝謝你能告訴我。’而不是:‘你今晚上得加10小時的班。’有時候,這做起來會有些困難,因為我們必須努力在最終期限之前完成’。但他們把問題告訴我,我就應該表示尊重;而且,只要我們的工作非常透明,我就可以跟客戶解釋。” ????在美國企業界,許多員工并不敢向老板報告壞消息。因為他們認為,告訴老板業務目標沒能實現,實際上是在跟她說“不”。但是,門羅公司的首席執行官里奇?謝里頓以及其他企業領導人卻認為,鼓勵員工說真話的企業文化,可以幫助公司做出更好的決策,培養員工的職業道德,并可以真正挖掘員工的集體智慧。 ????謝里頓認為,鼓勵員工對老板說“不”,可以使企業高層獲得一些新的好點子。他格外重視那些富有建設性的異議,并且愿意冒險采納來自員工的建議,通過培訓、制訂流程、與員工的定期溝通,把它融入到企業文化中。 ????公司很容易陷入一種“應聲蟲式”的企業文化,尤其是當員工感覺工作缺乏安全感的時候。為了形成一種開放溝通的氛圍,企業領導者必須獎勵和公布新的點子,鼓勵員工提出異議,甚至當所有人都太過順從的時候,要對員工提出質疑。 ????戴爾?卡耐基培訓(Dale Carnegie Training)的董事長彼得?韓鐸表示:“公司以及首席執行官和董事長都必須設定正確的基調。公司領導層最糟糕的,也是最致命的弱點,就是‘非我發明’的心態:‘如果不是我的主意,那就別講給我聽。’” ????如果員工感覺他們的意見得到傾聽,并對公司充滿了希望,他們會更努力地工作,效率也會更高。韓鐸表示:“這確實會鼓舞員工的士氣和奉獻精神,因為他們會感覺自己是公司的一份子;他們為公司付出了自己的努力。” 修補受損的企業文化 ????在接任南方保健公司(HealthSouth)首席執行官時,杰?格里尼面臨著嚴峻的挑戰。南方保健是一家位于美國伯明翰市的醫療保健公司,因一起重大的欺詐丑聞,該公司經歷了一場刑事和民事訴訟。 ????格里尼表示:“對我而言,最重要的是,重新建立一種與之前截然不同的企業文化。之前那種文化的特征是:敬畏、威脅、徇私,還有一位以自我為中心的首席執行官。” ????就職第一天,他便召開了全體員工大會,并在會上提出了他的商業愿景,以及在患者、全體員工和監管部門之間,實現公開、誠實、相互尊重和誠信的計劃。他開始舉辦季度員工大會,并專門在會議結束前設立了員工問答環節。如果會上沒有提出有挑戰性的問題,那么,高管將會針對他們擔憂的一些問題,向員工征求意見。 ????他說:“我認為,沒有任何單一的標準可以證明你的意圖。我必須通過我做的每件事,我選擇留在我身邊的那些人,把它表現出來。” ????而在環游旅行公司(Grand Circle ),員工將基于他們的開放式溝通獲得評分,開放式溝通是這家旅游服務公司的六大核心價值之一。在波士頓召開的每月例會上,高管們會用半個小時回答員工的問題。對于提出突出問題的員工,公司將在內部新聞通訊中提出表揚。 ????環游旅行公司的首席執行官阿蘭?里維斯表示:“他們將被視為冠軍或者榜樣。你之所以希望員工提出熱點問題,是因為你可以從這些問題中了解到公司發展的瓶頸……你也可以發現哪些環節存在組織性問題。” ????近期,根據與競爭對手一起旅游的員工給出的反饋,環游旅行公司對其亞馬遜河旅游路線進行了徹底改革。公司還取消了一款價值1,200萬美元的新型旅行預訂系統,因為員工們抱怨,這款定制軟件根本不起作用。 ????里維斯表示:“我相信,對于盡量聽取員工的意見,95%的美國企業都沒能做到,而且也不懂得如何開發員工的潛力。你必須要有能力處理各種批評意見。” ????當然,要鼓勵建設性的批評意見,而不是只知道抱怨的企業文化,這非常重要。實際上,戴爾卡耐基便培訓學員們,要以一種友好的方式提供反饋。 ????韓鐸表示:“為了以友好的方式提出異議,雙方都需要在相互尊重的基礎上,采取恰當的人際交往方式來解決問題。”他建議,在進行對話時,不要采用消極的方式,而應該用一種積極友好的方式打開話題。 ????在面對面談話和開會時,企業領導人可以創建一種安全的氛圍,供員工提出批評性意見。謝弗咨詢公司(Schaffer Consulting)高級合伙人羅恩?阿什肯納斯建議,牢記在幼兒園學到的規矩:禁止大聲叫喊或者辱罵,并且要堅持相互尊重的原則,以及基本的人類尊嚴。該公司位于美國康涅狄格州斯坦福德市。羅恩?阿什肯納斯著有《簡單有效》(Simply Effective)一書。 ????阿什肯納斯表示,有可能的話,可以將這些價值納入管理人員的績效評估。如果管理人員完成了業績目標,卻未能實現企業文化預期,那么你需要對其進行公開地批評。(參閱:《在文化理念上與公司契合的員工是否比有經驗的員工更值得聘用?》) ????誰都不希望因為“老板永遠正確”的企業文化,導致公司發展停滯,并使員工失去積極性。他認為:“如果在一個企業的工作環境中,員工只需要鞠躬敬禮,卻不能暢所欲言,這會使公司逐漸失去發展的動力和活力。” ????而且,一線員工通常更了解客戶的需求與顧慮。如果銷售人員感覺獲得了支持,他們也會取得更優秀的銷售業績。 當你正被“被應聲蟲打垮”時 ????作為老板,你正面臨應聲蟲的問題?希望得到預警嗎? ????韓鐸表示:“如果你的觀點沒有任何人反對,那是因為他們害怕提出異議。沒有人會永遠正確。我經常看到,由于高級管理層的固執己見,致使許多公司陷入危機。” ????作為企業領導人,如果你想鼓勵溝通,那你需要注意自己的面部表情、音調,還有肢體語言。韓鐸建議,要采用開放式站姿,避免雙臂交叉抱于胸前的姿勢。 ????肢體語言對雙方都可以產生效果。2008年年末,時值金融危機,南方保健公司的格里尼正與公司的代理首席財務官開會,討論計劃提交給華爾街的公司收益預期。這位代理首席財務官沒有對格里尼的侵略性姿勢提出異議,但他的肢體語言和面部表情卻把他的想法顯露無遺。 ????格里尼回憶道:“我能看得出,他感覺不大舒服。然后我說:‘我的這種姿勢,是不是讓你感到不舒服?’”最終,鑒于首席財務官的擔憂,南方保健給出的預期,比格里尼最初的提議更為保守,而事實證明,這個決定是正確的。 ????當員工意識到,他們獲得了管理層的支持時,他們會更努力地工作。但是格里尼認為,最大的回報在于,這么做可以為公司留住最有才干的高級管理人員。如果是在沉悶的環境中,這些高管們可能最早選擇離開,結果只能是由那些只為領薪水的人頂替。 ????總之,有時候你需要員工對老板說“不”,因為沒有人能無所不知。格里尼表示:“擔任首席執行官最容易犯的一個錯誤是,你會開始驕傲自滿。企業界到處都是自大狂掌管一切的例子。” |
????Imagine going to your boss with news of a delayed project or cost overrun, and hearing "thank you" in response. ????That's the rule at Menlo Innovations, a software company based in Ann Arbor, Mich., which trains project managers to smile and thank employees even when they're bearing bad news. ????"My job is to say, 'Thank you for letting me know,' not 'I need you to work an extra 10 hours tonight,'" says Lisa Ho, 26, a Menlo project manager. "Sometimes it's hard to do because we have this deadline we're trying to meet. But I respect them for telling me and as long as we're very transparent… I can call the client." ????In corporate America, many employees are afraid to report bad news because they're essentially saying no to the boss -- telling her that a business goal hasn't been met. But companies that foster a fear-free culture enjoy better decision-making, more ethical behavior and the ability to truly harness the collective brainpower of the workforce, according to Menlo CEO Rich Sheridan and other business leaders. ????Encouraging employees to say no to the boss ensures that smart new ideas bubble to the top levels of an organization, Sheridan says. He sets such a high priority on healthy dissent that he's baked it into the corporate culture through training, procedures, regular communications to employees and a willingness to take risks based on staff suggestions. ????It's all too easy to fall into a yes-man culture, especially when workers feel insecure about their jobs. To create an environment of open communication, leaders must reward and publicize new ideas, encourage dissent from staff and even challenge employees when everyone seems too agreeable. ????"The company and the CEO and the chairman have to set the right tone," says Peter Handal, president of Dale Carnegie Training. "The worst, fatal flaw in the leadership of companies is the 'not invented here' mentality: 'If it's not my idea, I don't want to hear it.'" ????Employees will work harder and more efficiently because they feel listened to and invested in the venture, he says. "It really does help the morale and the spirit and the dedication of the people in the company because they feel like they're part of it; they've given their input," Handal says. Mending a frayed company culture ????Jay Grinney faced an especially tough challenge when he took over as CEO of HealthSouth, a Birmingham-based health care company, in the wake of a massive fraud scandal that led to criminal and civil lawsuits. ????"One of the things that was important to me was to create a culture that would be in stark contrast to the culture that was here before I arrived," Grinney says. "That culture was characterized by fear, intimidation, favoritism, a very ego-centric CEO." ????On his first day, he called a company-wide employee meeting and presented his vision for the business and a plan to establish openness, honesty, mutual respect and integrity with patients, fellow HealthSouth employees and regulators. He began to hold quarterly town hall meetings that end with a question and answer session for employees. If no challenging questions emerge, top managers will ask about issues they know are raising concerns. ????"I don't think there's any single formula for proving your intent," he says. "It has to be demonstrated in every single thing that I do and has to be reflected in the people I surround myself with." ????At Grand Circle Corp., employees are graded on their open communication, one of the travel and cruise company's six key values. During a monthly meeting in Boston, executives answer staff questions for a half hour, and the people who ask outstanding questions are recognized in the company's newsletter. ????"They're viewed as the champions or the role models," explains Grand Circle CEO Alan Lewis. "The reason you want your associates to raise hot issues is that's where you'll learn about bottlenecks…. You'll see where you have organizational issues." ????Recently, Grand Circle overhauled its Amazon River itinerary based on feedback from employees that had vacationed with a competitor. The company eliminated a brand new, $12 million travel reservation system after associates complained that the custom-built software simply didn't work. ????"I believe 95% of corporate America doesn't try to listen to their associates, doesn't know how to get to the brainpower of their organization," Lewis says. "You have to be able to handle a lot of criticism." ????Of course, it's important to encourage constructive criticism rather than a culture of complaint. In fact, Dale Carnegie trains people to offer feedback in a friendly way. ????"In order to disagree agreeably, both sides need to handle things with respect and the proper interpersonal approach," Handal says. He recommends opening the conversation with a friendly approach and something positive, rather than beginning with the negative. ????Leaders can create a safe space for critical feedback during one-on-one interactions and meetings. Remember your kindergarten rules: no yelling or abuse, and stick to the principles of respect, and the basics of human dignity, says Ron Ashkenas, a senior partner at Schaffer Consulting, based in Stamford, Conn., and author of Simply Effective. ????When possible, build these values into managers' performance assessments and don't be afraid to make public firings when people hit their numbers but fail to meet cultural expectations, Ashkenas says. (See: Is it better to hire for cultural fit over experience?) ????You want to avoid the stagnation and time clock-punching that can result from a culture where the boss is always right. "It's draining and de-energizing when people are in an environment when they just have to salute and not be themselves," he says. ????Moreover, employees on the front lines often have better information about customer needs and concerns, and sales staff members do a better job selling when they feel like they are supported. When you are being 'yessed to death' ????Looking for a warning sign that you're a boss with a yes-man problem? ????"If you're saying things that nobody disagrees with, people are afraid to disagree. Nobody is right all the time," Handal says. "I've seen companies get into very serious trouble by having a very closed mind at the top." ????Be conscious of your facial expressions, tone of voice and body language if you're a leader trying to encourage communication. Use an open stance rather than crossing your arms in front of your chest, Handal advises. ????Body language can work both ways. In late 2008 during the financial crisis, HealthSouth's Grinney was meeting with his acting chief financial officer about earnings guidance the company planned to give Wall Street. The acting CFO didn't disagree with Grinney's somewhat aggressive position, but something seemed off about his body language and facial expression. ????"I could just tell he wasn't entirely comfortable. I said, 'You're not comfortable with this position, are you?'" Grinney recalls. In the end, HealthSouth ended up going with more conservative guidance than Grinney initially proposed, due to the CFO's concerns, which was the right call. ????Employees work harder when they know they have their manager's backing. But the big payoff is in keeping the most talented executives, who would be the first to leave a stifling environment -- only to be replaced by people who are just in it for a paycheck, he says. ????Ultimately, you need people to say no to the boss sometimes, because nobody has all the answers. "One of the pitfalls of being the CEO is you can start believing your own press," Grinney says. "The business world is full of examples of hubris taking over." |